The Geography of Transport Systems

Previous Next

th_energysrc.gif (1290 bytes)
Sources of Energy

th_evolenergy.gif (1346 bytes)
Energy Content of some Combustibles


Power Generated by Steam Machines, Europe, 1840-1888

th_evolenergy.gif (1346 bytes)
Evolution of Energy Sources


World Energy Production (in Terawatts), 2006


Global Energy Systems Transition


World Energy Consumption, 1965-2006

th_energymode.gif (2392 bytes)
Transportation Modes and Energy

th_transportenergy.gif (1279 bytes)
Energy Used by the Transportation System


Factors of Fuel Use by Transportation


Transportation Fuel Markets

th_oecdoil.gif (1350 bytes)
World Oil Energy Consumption by Sector, 1973-2004

th_oecdoil.gif (1350 bytes)
Demand for Refined Petroleum Products by Sector in the United States, 1960-2005

th_oecdoil.gif (1350 bytes)
Energy Consumption by Mode of Transportation in the United States, 1960-2004


Energy Consumption by Road Transportation in the United States, 1970-2004

th_transportenergy.gif (1279 bytes)
Typical Energy Use for a Car


Retail Motor Gasoline Prices in Selected Countries, 1990-2006


Average Gasoline Consumption for New Vehicles, United States, 1972-2007

th_transportenergy.gif (1279 bytes)
Total Motor Vehicle Fuel Consumption and Travel in the United States


Trend in Aircraft Fuel Efficiency (Fuel burned per Seat)


Sport Utility Vehicle


Fuel Consumption and Fuel Efficiency

th_emissions.gif (1365 bytes)
Automobile Emission Factors


Peak Oil


The Third Oil Shock: West Texas Intermediate, Monthly Spot Oil Price (1946-2008)


Potential Impacts of High Oil Prices on Transportation


Costs of Shipping a 40 foot Container From China to the American East Coast


Chapter 8 - Concepts (PowerPoint)

Transportation and Energy

Authors : Dr. Jean-Paul Rodrigue and Dr. Claude Comtois

1. Energy

Human activities are closely dependant on the usage of several forms and sources of energy used to perform work. From a physical perspective, energy is movement or the possibility of creating movement, which can be ordered (mechanical energy) or disordered (thermal energy). It exists in potential (stored) and kinetic (used) forms. Energy content is the available energy per unit of weight or volume for an energy source. Thus, the more energy consumed the greater the amount of work realized. There exist four types of physical work related to human activities [Chapman, 1989]:

Through the history of mankind's use of energy, the choice of an energy source depended on a number of utility factors which as time progresses involve a transition in energy systems from solid, liquid and eventually gas energy. Since the industrial revolution, many efforts have been made to have as much work as possible performed by machines, which considerably improved industrial productivity. At the beginning of the 21st century, the transition reached a stage where fossil fuels, notably petroleum, are dominant. Out of the world’s power consumption of about 15 terawatts a year, 86% is derived from fossil fuels.

A recent trend has also been a shift on the purpose of energy use. Work related to the transportation of goods, people and information has increased significantly, on par with the globalization of the economy. This implies a growing share of transportation in the total amount of energy spent for maintaining and improving the range and scope of human activities. Energy consumption has a strong correlation with the level of development. Among developed countries, transportation now accounts between 20 and 25% of all the energy being consumed.

2. Transportation and Energy Consumption

The relationship between transport and energy is a direct one, but subject to different interpretations since it concerns different transport modes, each having a specific performance  level. There is often a compromise between speed and energy consumption, related to the desired economic returns. Passengers and high value goods can be transported by  Economies of scale, mainly those achieved by maritime transportation are linked to low levels of energy consumption per unit of mass being transported, but at a low speed. Comparatively, air freight has high energy consumption levels, linked to high speed services. Many activities related to transportation consume energy:

A powerful trend that has emerged in the 1950s has been the growing share of transportation in the total oil consumption of developed countries. The transport sector accounts for more than 57% of all the oil used each year around the world. More specifically, petroleum products now account for more than 97% of the energy consumption by transportation modes. While the use of petroleum for other economic sectors, such as industrial and electricity generation, has remained relatively stable, the growth in oil demand is mainly attributed to the growth in transportation demand. Energy consumption has strong modal variations:

The private car has a poor energetic performance, although this performance has seen substantial improvements since the 1970s, mainly due to growing energy prices and regulations. Only 12% of the fuel used by a car actually provides momentum. Considering this performance, the level of car ownership is a direct indicator of energy consumption for the transport sector. The United States had one of the highest levels of car ownership in the world, 773 motor vehicles per 1,000 people in 1997. About 60% of all American households owned two or more cars, with 19% owning three or more. A more disturbing trend has been the massive diffusion of sport utility vehicles, major consumers of hydrocarbons, particularly in suburban areas. Fuel consumption is however impacted by diminishing returns, implying that higher levels of fuel efficiency involve declining marginal gains in fuel consumption.

3. Combustion of Hydrocarbons

Since almost all transportation modes depend on the internal combustion engine, it is worth investigating the chemical combustion principle of hydrocarbons. For the majority of internal combustion engines, gasoline (C8H18; four strokes Otto-cycle engines) serves as fuel, but other sources like methane (CH4; gas turbines), diesel (mostly trucks) and kerosene (turbofans of jet planes) are used. In a complete and perfect combustion of gasoline the following chemical reaction is achieved:

Gasoline produces around 46,000 Btu per kilogram combusted, which requires from 16 to 24 kg of air. The energy released by combustion causes a rise in temperature of the products of combustion. Several factors and conditions influence the level of combustion in an internal combustion engine to provide momentum and keep efficient operating conditions. The temperature attained depends on the rate of release and dissipation of the energy and the quantity of combustion products. Air is the most available source of oxygen, but because air also contains vast quantities of nitrogen, nitrogen becomes the major constituent of the products of combustion. The rate of combustion may be increased by finely dividing the fuel to increase its surface area and hence its rate of reaction, and by mixing it with the air to provide the necessary amount of oxygen to the fuel.

If all internal combustion engines worked according to the above equation, emissions and thus local environmental impacts of transportation would be negligible (except for carbon dioxide emissions). The problem is that combustion in internal combustion engines is imperfect and incomplete for two reasons:

In addition to the imperfect and incomplete combustion of hydrocarbons, three major factors influence the rate of combustion and thus emissions of pollutants: characteristics of vehicles, driving characteristics, and atmospheric conditions.

4. Transportation and Alternative Fuels

All other things being equal, the energy source with the lowest cost will always be sought. The dominance of petroleum fuels is a result of the relative simplicity with which they can be stored and efficiently used in the internal combustion engine vehicle. The transportation sector is heavily dependent on the use of petroleum fuels for obvious reasons. Other fossil fuels (natural gas, propane, and methanol) can be used as transportation fuels but require a more complicated storage system. The main issue concerning the large-scale uses of these alternative vehicle fuels is the large capital investments require in distribution facilities as compared with conventional fuels. Another issue is that in terms of energy density, these alternative fuels have lower efficiency than gasoline and thus require greater volume of on-board storage to cover the equivalent distance as a gasoline propelled vehicle. Alternative fuels in the form of non-crude oil resources are drawing considerable attention as a result of shrinking oil reserves, increasing petroleum costs and the need to reduce emissions of harmful pollutants:

The penetration of non fossil fuels in the transportation sector has serious limitations. As a result, the price of oil will certainly continue to increase as more expensive fuel-recovery technologies will have to be utilized with soaring demand for gasoline. But high oil prices are inflationary leading to recession in economic activity, the search for alternative sources of energy and a short term decline in the demand. Already, the peaking of conventional oil production is leading to the implementation of coal derived oil projects. Coal liquefaction technology allows the transformation of coal into refined oil after a series of processes in an environment of high temperature and high pressure. While the cost-effectiveness of this technique as yet to be demonstrated, coal liquefaction is an important measure in the implementation of transportation fuel strategies in coal-rich countries, such as China.

The costs of alternative energy sources to fossil fuels are higher in the transportation sector than in other types of economic activities. This suggests higher competitive advantages for the industrial, household, commercial, electricity and heat sectors to shift away from oil and to rely on solar, wind or hydro-power. Transportation fuels based on renewable energy sources might not be competitive with petroleum fuels unless future price increase is affected by different fuel taxes based on environmental impacts.

5. Transportation and Peak Oil

The extent to which conventional non-renewable fossil fuels will continue to be the primary resources for nearly all transportation fuels is subject to debate. Some studies estimate global resources for oil at about a trillion barrels. This represents 30 years of reserves at present rate of consumption. But the gap between demand and supply, once considerable, is narrowing, an effect compounded by the peaking off of global oil production. The steady surge in demand from China and India requires an additional output of 2-3 million barrels a day. This raises concern about the capacity of major oil producers to meet this rising world demand. The producers are not running out of oil, but the existing reservoirs may not be capable of producing on a daily basis the increasing volumes of oil that the world requires. Reservoirs do not exist as underground lakes from which oil can easily be extracted. There are geological limits to the output of existing fields. This suggests that an additional 4-5 million barrels a day need to be found to compensate for the declining production of existing fields. Reserves additions in Alaska, off-shore West Africa or the Caspian Sea basin are not enough to offset this growing demand (Mass, 2005). The current situation thus underlines forces that interact to create an environment involving higher oil prices; the supply appears to be unable to keep up with the demand. Peak oil is what it means, a physical inability to provide a higher level of oil supply. It must also been considered that rising oil prices are the outcome of the systematic debasement of most fiat currencies through the inflation of the money supply, this in addition to any physical shortages (the current environment appears to be compounding both). So, even if a resource such as petroleum could be supplied adequately, monetary policies followed by most central banks and governments guarantee higher energy prices.

Other studies argue that the history of the oil industry is marked by cycles of shortages and surplus (Johansson, 2003). The rising price of oil will render cost effective oil recovery in difficult areas or from lower quality sources. Deep water drilling or extraction from tar sands should increase the supply of oil that can be recovered and extracted from the surface. But there is a limit to the capacity of technological innovation to find and extract more oil around the world. Technological development does not keep pace with surging demand. The construction of drilling rigs, power plants, refineries and pipelines designed to increase oil exploitation is a complex, expensive and slow process. The main concern is the amount of oil that can be pumped to the surface on a daily basis, especially where major oil fields have reached peak capacity. Under such circumstances, oil prices are bound to raise in a substantial way, sending significant price signals to the transport market. How the transport system will respond and adapt to higher energy prices is obviously subject to much debate and interpretations. The following potential consequences can be noted:

As the reality of peak oil steps in, the next stage is likely to be a growing level of unreliability in the supply system as shortages become more prevalent and common. At least, higher prices will trigger notable changes in usage, modes, networks and supply chain management. From a macro perspective, and since transportation is a very complex system, assessing the outcome of high energy prices remains hazardous. What appears very likely is a strong rationalization, a shift towards more energy efficient modes as well as a higher level of integration between modes to create multiplying effects in energy efficiency. As higher transport costs play in, namely for containers, many manufacturing activities will reconsider the locations of production facilities to sites closer to markets. While globalization was favored by cheap and efficient transport systems, the new relationships between transport and energy are likely to restructure the global structure of production and distribution.

Copyright © 1998-2008, Dr. Jean-Paul Rodrigue, Dept. of Economics & Geography, Hofstra University. For personal or classroom use ONLY. This material (including graphics) is not public domain and cannot be published, in whole or in part, in ANY form (printed or electronic) and on any media without consent. Permission MUST be requested prior to use.

06/22/08