The Geography of Transport Systems

Previous Next


International Seaborne Trade and Exports of Goods, 1955-2005


Domains of Maritime Circulation


Types of Maritime Routes

th_amoco.jpg (1978 bytes)
Amoco Cadiz

th_exon_val.jpg (1590 bytes)
Exxon Valdez


Length of the Major Inland Waterway Systems, 2000


Evergreen Round-the-World Route, Westbound, 2001


Three Major Pendulum Routes Serviced by OOCL, 2006
Detailed PDF Map

th_maritimeenclaves.gif (1480 bytes)
Maritime Enclaves


World Registered Fleet, 1914-2000


Liner Transatlantic Crossing Times, 1838 – 1952 (in days)


Channel Ferry Ship Entering the Port of Le Havre, France

th_maritime6090.gif (2093 bytes)
Maritime Traffic per Continent and Ocean, 1960-1990
Detailed PDF Map


World’s Largest Dry-Bulk Carrier, the Berge Stalh

th_tonskmmaritime.gif (1165 bytes)
Tons-Miles Shipped by Maritime Transportation, 1970-2005


T2 Tanker, 1943


VLCC Atlantic Prosperity


LNG Ship


The Regina Maersk

th_lakersteelco.jpg (2135 bytes)
Laker Ship Supplying a Steel Mill in Hamilton, Ontario
(Google Earth Placemark)


Operating Costs of Panamax and Post-panamax Containerships


RO-RO Cargo Ship


Vessel Size Groups (in dead weight tons)


Merchant Fleet of the World, Tonnage Registered per Ship Size, 1985-2000


Cargo, Trade and Ship Characteristics


Maritime Shipping Characteristics

th_registships.gif (1177 bytes)
Tonnage by Country of Registry, 2003


International and Domestic Short-Sea Shipping Characteristics

th_stlawrencesys.gif (1566 bytes)
The St. Lawrence / Great Lakes System


Inland Waterway Traffic, Western Europe, 1970-2000


Fluvial Transport System, Lower Yangtze Delta


Types of Pendulum Routes


Factors Impacting Maritime Networks


Pendulum Services and Cabotage


Chapter 3 - Concepts (PowerPoint - Part I)

Maritime Transportation

Authors : Dr. Jean-Paul Rodrigue, Dr. Brian Slack and Dr. Theo Notteboom

1. Overview

From its modest origins as Egyptian coastal sailships around 3,200 BC, maritime transportation has always been the dominant support of global trade. By 1,200 BC Egyptian ships traded at Sumatra, representing one of the longest maritime route of that time. With the development of the steam engine in the mid 19th century, this role expanded considerably as ships were no longer subject to dominant wind patterns. This long term attribute has been reinforced by recent trends where changes in international trade and seaborne trade are interrelated. Maritime transportation, like all transportation, is a derived demand. This represents about 80% of all freight shipped globally, a figure similar to the share of the world's surface covered by oceans. In terms of weight, about 96% of the world trade is carried by maritime transportation. Maritime shipping is one of the most globalized industry in terms of ownership.

Maritime transportation, similar to land and air modes, operates on its own space, which is at the same time geographical by its physical attributes, strategic by its control and commercial by its usage. While geographical considerations tend to be constant in time, strategic and especially commercial considerations are much more dynamic. The physiography of maritime transportation is composed of two major elements, which are rivers and oceans. Although they are connected, each represents a specific domain of maritime circulation. The notion of maritime transportation rests on the existence of regular itineraries, better known as maritime routes.

Maritime routes. Corridors of a few kilometers in width trying to avoid the discontinuities of land transport by linking ports, the main elements of the maritime / land interface. Maritime routes are a function of obligatory points of passage, which are strategic places, of physical constraints (coasts, winds, marine currents, depth, reefs, ice) and of political borders. As a result, maritime routes draw arcs on the earth water surface as intercontinental maritime transportation tries to follow the great circle distance.

The most recent technological transformations affecting water transport have concentrated on modifying water canals (such as dredging port channels to higher depths), and on increasing the size, the automation and the specialization of vessels (e.g. container ships, tanker, bulk carrier). These transformations partially explain the development of maritime traffic that has been adapting to increasing energy demand (mainly fossil fuels), the movements of raw materials and the location of major grain markets. This massification of transport into regular flows over long distances is not without consequences when accidents affecting oil tankers can lead to major ecological disasters (e.g. Amoco Cadiz, Exxon Valdez).

Fluvial transportation, even if slow and inflexible, offers a high capacity and a continuous flow. The fluvial / land interface often relies less on transshipment infrastructures and is thus more permissive for the location of dependent activities. Ports are less relevant to fluvial transportation but fluvial hub centers experiences a growing integration with maritime and land transportation, notably since the emergence of containers. The degree of integration for fluvial transportation varies from totally isolated distribution systems to well integrated ones. In regions well supplied by hydrographic networks, fluvial transportation can be a privileged mode of shipment between economic activities. In fact, several industrial regions have emerged in along major fluvial axis. More recently, river-sea navigation is also providing a new dimension to fluvial transportation by establishing a direct interface between fluvial and maritime systems.

The majority of maritime circulation takes place along coastlines and three continents have limited fluvial trade; Africa, Australia and Asia (except China). There are however large fluvial waterway systems in North America, Europe and China over which significant fluvial circulation takes place. Despite regular services on selected fluvial arteries, such as the Yangtze, the potential of waterways for passenger transport remains limited to fluvial tourism. Most major maritime infrastructures involve maintaining or modifying waterways to establish more direct routes (navigation channels and canals). This strategy is however very expensive and undertaken only when necessary. Significant investments have been made in expanding transshipment capacities of ports, which is also very expensive as ports are heavy consumers of space.

The importance of maritime routes has changed with economic development and technical improvements. For instance, containerization changed the configuration of freight routes with innovative services. Prior to containerization, loading or unloading a ship was a very expensive and time consuming task and a cargo ship typically spent more time docked than at sea. With faster and lower transshipment costs pendulum routes, which tend to be highly flexible in terms of which ports are serviced, have however emerged as the favorite form of containerized maritime circulation.

Pendulum service. Involves a set of sequential port calls along a maritime range, commonly including a transoceanic service from ports in another range and structured as a continuous loop. They are almost exclusively used for container transportation with the purpose of servicing a market by balancing the number of port calls and the frequency of services.

The most extensive pendulum services are known as "round-the-world" routes as major maritime ranges of the world are services along a continuous loop. Another recent trend has also been the integration and specialization of several routes with feeder ships converging at major maritime hubs. For instance, fluvial-maritime ships enable to go directly from the fluvial to the oceanic maritime network. This is notably the case for Europe (Mediterranean, North Sea and the Baltic).

Not every territory has a direct access to the ocean. Maritime enclaves are such countries that have difficulties to undertake maritime trade since they are not part of an oceanic domain of maritime circulation. This requires agreements with neighboring countries to have access to a port facility through a road, a rail line or through a river. However, being an enclave does not necessarily imply an exclusion from international trade, but substantially higher transport costs which may impair economic development.

2. Maritime Freight

Maritime traffic is dominantly focused on freight. Before the era of intercontinental air transportation, transcontinental passenger services were assumed by liner passenger ships, dominantly over the North Atlantic. Passengers are now a marginal leisure function solely serviced by cruise shipping. Several oceanic ferry services are also in operation over short distances, namely in Western Europe (Channel; Baltic Sea), Japan and Southeast Asia (Indonesia). The systematic growth of maritime freight traffic has been fueled by:

Maritime traffic is commonly measured in deadweight tons, which refers to the amount of cargo that can be loaded on an "empty" ship, without exceeding its operational design limits. This limit is often identified as a loadline, which is the maximal draft of the ship. Maritime freight is conventionally considered in two categories:

Bulk cargo. Refers to freight, both dry or liquid, that is not packaged such as minerals (oil, coal, iron ore) and grains. It often requires the use of specialized ships such as oil tankers as well as specialized transshipment and storage facilities. Conventionally, this cargo has a single origin, destination and client. It is also prone to economies of scale.

Break-bulk cargo. Refers to general cargo that has been packaged in some way with the use of bags, boxes or drums. This cargo tends to have numerous origins, destinations and clients. Before containerization, economies of scale were difficult to achieve with break-bulk cargo as the loading and unloading process was very labor and time consuming.

There are four broad types of ships employed around the world:

The distinctions in vessel types are further differentiated by the kinds of services on which they are deployed. Bulk ships tend to operate on both on a regular schedule between two ports or on voyage basis. In the latter case the ship may haul cargoes between different ports based on demand. General cargo vessels operate on liner services, in which the vessels are employed on a regular scheduled service between fixed ports of call, or as tramp ships, where the vessels have no schedule and move between ports based on cargo availability.

3. Maritime Shipping

Maritime shipping is dominated by bulk cargo, which roughly accounted for 69.6% of all the ton-miles shipped in 2005, but the share of break-bulk cargo is increasing steadily, mainly because of containerization. Shipping has traditionally faced two drawbacks. It is slow, with speeds at sea averaging 15 knots (26 Km/hr). Secondly, delays are encountered in ports where loading and unloading takes place. The latter may involve several days of handling when break-bulk cargo was concerned. These drawbacks are particularly constraining where goods have to be moved over short distances or where shippers require rapid service deliveries. However, technical improvements tend to blur the distinction between bulk and break-bulk cargo, as both can be unitized on pallets and increasingly in containers. For instance, it is possible, and increasingly common, to ship grain and oil, both bulk cargoes, in a container. Consequently, the amount of containerized freight has grown substantially, from 23% of all cargo in 1980, 40% in 1990 to 70% in 2000.

Geographically, maritime traffic has evolved considerably over the last decades especially through growth in transpacific trade. By establishing commercial linkages between continents, maritime transport supports a considerable traffic that covers 90% of the intercontinental transport demand of freight. The strength of maritime transport does not rest on its speed, but on its capacity and on the continuity of its traffic. Railway and road transportation are simply not able to support a traffic at such a geographical scale and intensity. Heavy industrial activities that use bulk raw materials are generally adjacent to port sites, benefiting from load breaks. The average haul length was about 4,200 miles.

Maritime shipping has seen several major technical innovations aiming at improving the performance of ships or their access to port facilities, notably in the 20th century. They include:

4. Maritime Economics

An important feature of the economics of shipping relates to its capital costs. Because of their size, ships represent a significant capital outlay. Cruise ships represent the most expensive class of vessels, with the Queen Mary 2 costing $800 million, but even a container ship represents an initial capital outlays of $75 million. The annual cost of servicing the purchase of these vessels represents the largest single item of operating expenditures, typically accounting for over half of the annual operating costs. Container shipping requires the deployment of many vessels to maintain a regular service (14 ships in the case of a typical Far East – Europe service), which is a severe constraint on the entry of new players. On the other hand, older second-hand vessels may be purchased for much smaller amounts, and sometimes the purchase price can be easily covered by a few successful voyages. In some regards, therefore, the shipping industry is quite open and historically has provided opportunities for entrepreneurs to accumulate large fortunes. Many of the largest fleets are in private hands, owned by individuals or by family groups.

The main advantage of maritime transportation is obviously its economies of scale, making it the cheapest per unit of all transport modes, which fits well for heavy industrial activities. On the other hand, maritime transportation has one of the highest entry costs of the transport sector. Typically, a ship has an economic life between 15 and 20 years and thus represents a significant investment that must be amortized. For instance, a Panamax containership can cost $50,000 per day to operate with most of the expenses related fuel and port charges. The operation of the maritime transport system requires financing that can come from two sources:

In the past, governments have intervened, often massively, in the maritime sector to fulfill different goals such as economic development, national defense, prestige, balance of payments, and the protection of the national industry. To reach those goals, governments relied on methods such as regulations, subsidies, national fleets, preference of cargo and ports of entry. Cabotage regulations have been one of the privileged measures to protect the national maritime transportation industry.

Cabotage. Transport between two terminals (a terminal of loading/embarkment and a terminal of unloading/ disembarkment) located in the same country irrespective of the country in which the mode providing the service is registered. Cabotage is often subject to restrictions and regulations. Under such circumstances, each nation reserves for its national carriers the right to move domestic freight or passengers traffic.

Many cabotage laws were implemented, such as the Passenger Services Act of 1886, which placed cabotage restrictions on oceanborne passenger travel in the United States. In the same line, the Merchant Marine (Jones) Act of 1920 implemented cabotage regulations for freight. The shipping industry has a very international character. This is reflected particularly in terms of ownership and flagging. The ownership of ships is very broad. While a ship may be owned by a Greek family or a US Corporation, it may be flagged under another nationality. The use of flags of convenience is a mean by which ship owners can obtain lower registration fees, lower operating costs and fewer restrictions. The maritime industry is now more deregulated than before because of technical changes, mainly containerization and open registry ships operating under fiscal shelters. By 1998, about 46% of the ships and about 62% of the global tonnage was registered under a flag of convenience.

5. Shipping Services and Networks

The maritime shipping industry offers two major types of services:

An important historic feature of oceanic liner transport is the operation of "conferences". These are formal agreements between companies engaged on particular trading routes. They fix the rates charged by the individual lines, operating for example between Northern Europe and the East Coast of North America, or eastbound between Northern Asia and the West Coast of North America. Over the years in excess of 100 such conference arrangements have been established. While they may be seen as anti-competitive, the conference system has always escaped prosecution from national anti-trust agencies. This is because they are seen as a mechanism to stabilize rates in an industry that is inherently unstable, with significant variations in supply of ship capacity and market demand. By fixing rates exporters are given protection from swings in prices, and are guaranteed a regular level of service provision (Brooks, 2000). Firms compete on the basis of service provision rather than price.

A new form of inter-firm organization has emerged in the container shipping industry since the mid-1990s. Because of the costs of providing ship capacity to more and more markets are escalating beyond the means of many carriers, many of the largest shipping lines have come together by forming strategic alliances with erstwhile competitors. They offer joint services by pooling vessels on the main commercial routes. In this way they are each able to commit fewer ships to a particular service route, and deploy the extra ships on other routes that are maintained outside the alliance. The alliance services are marketed separately, but operationally involve close cooperation in selecting ports of call and in establishing schedules. The alliance structure has led to significant developments in route alignments and the economies of scale of container shipping (Slack, 2004). The consequences have been a concentration of ownership, particularly in container shipping. The 20 largest carriers controlled 26% of the world slot capacity in 1980, 42% cent in 1992 and about 58% in 2003. Those carriers have the responsibility to establish and maintain profitable routes in a competitive environment. This involves three major decisions about how such a maritime network takes shape (Notteboom, 2006):

Since many container shipping services have a pendulum structure, cabotage imposes some restrictions on these services.

Copyright © 1998-2008, Dr. Jean-Paul Rodrigue, Dept. of Economics & Geography, Hofstra University. For personal or classroom use ONLY. This material (including graphics) is not public domain and cannot be published, in whole or in part, in ANY form (printed or electronic) and on any media without consent. Permission MUST be requested prior to use.

03/09/08